or leaders as being part of the internal 'enemies'...
During the last year, as
the political and economic crisis in Somaliland has deepened, there has been a
growing and disturbing trend in Somaliland’s political discourse with an increasing
talk of the country having
many ‘enemies’. This worrying narrative based on
politics of ‘enmity’, xenophobia projecting outward to blame others for failure
inside, is visible in social media where people accuse one another of being
‘internal’
and ‘external’ enemies of the country. Sadly, you get a flavor of
this thinking even from government statements and from politicians’ and leaders'
speeches through every media available to them. While trying to
make sense of
the current political crisis and ascribing reasons to internal and external
‘enemies’ undermining Somaliland. And even in the public debate people are
accusing certain clans, opposition parties
or leaders as being part of the
internal ‘enemies’ of Somaliland. Regularly, accusations are made of meddling
in Somaliland, against governments of neighboring Puntland, Somali region of
Ethiopia, and even the Federal Government of Somalia are added to the global
nemesis of China in being suspected or accused of being part of the ‘external’
enemies.
The fundamental flaw with
this narrative is that it does not differentiate between an enemy and an
adversary, while a political adversary is someone you want to defeat
politically, as their ideas or interest are contrary to
yours, while an enemy
is someone you must destroy as he wants to destroy you. Between adversaries’
trust is possible as we seek to turn discussion, often heated, into dialogue to
move us all forward. Positively. But with
enemies’ compromise is not possible
and if negotiation is undertaken at the wrong time, it can be seen as defeat as
extremes set agendas creating enmity where there was discussion if not dialogue
for the common
good. Today's political adversary could become tomorrow's
allies, as compromise is possible with an adversary to ensure the majority, the
common good, are at the heart in moving forward. It’s quite possible
that with
the emergence of new challenges or a great crisis the region is confronted
with, make it detrimental to forge new alliances with adversaries and there
might even be a situation that one is even forced to call on the support of
those that are today labelled as ‘enemies’.
The second problem is that even
though Somaliland is not recognized politically as a sovereign state, it claims
to be an independent entity and exercises its sovereignty, engaging in
international relations with countries.
Somaliland’s Government should
understand in international relations the saying goes "there are no permanent
friends or no perennial enemies, only there are permanent national interests”. Every
country in the
world follows a discourse based on its own national interest,
even if it opposes or is contrary to another country’s interest and politics, this
is what a country’s politicians do as they drive statecraft even in the
relation with their friendly neighboring countries, they might take steps or
follow policies that undermine one another. It is at this point statecraft
comes into play. Diplomats are regularly the middle ground, tempering
the
excesses of political extremes and ensuring the regular political changes are
smoothed to ensure socio-economic relations are the center ground on which
livelihood and people’s wellbeing is founded. With the
politicization of
diplomacy regularly experienced in newer states, states where democracy is yet
to have a depth to temper the excesses created by trends in media pandering to
different political agendas, the insidious slide from adversarial politics into
outright conflict is far too prevalent.
Thirdly, the consequence of this
political narrative of ‘enmity’ is that it further adds to the heightened
political polarization that Somaliland was facing and can contribute to a sense
of social tension which undermines the social cohesion and lead to undermining the
socio-economic fabric of the society and gradually even lead to tearing
communities and families apart. This is often the recipe that contributes
to the start of conflicts,
fighting, insecurity, crisis and instability, which
should make one extremely vigilant. On the economic side, the climate of
hostility can have a further negative effect on an already stagnating economy
in the region, as
social capital effects economic perceptions and potentially
interferes with economic choices that people make and trade in the region.
Already it’s reported that trade with neighboring regions have severely
declined
over the last months, severely undermining Somaliland’s ambition to
become a logistical and trade hub for the region. This vision will only be
feasible with a socio-political culture that can attract and positively enable
economic linkages, trade and doing business, an open trade culture that showcases
a mindset of civility, diplomacy, open communication, curiosity and tolerance,
all traits that people from Somaliland once used to be well known for.
And lastly, putting faults
and blame of the current political crisis on ‘internal and external political
actors portray an unwillingness of political elites to take responsibility for
their own politics and actions that have led
to the current multifaceted socio,
political and economic crisis. As long as one avoids taking responsibility it
will be challenging to reflect on what went wrong and find a way out of the
current crisis; this realisation and
understanding is part of political
maturity Somaliland had commenced to achieve and now seems to be losing with
great alacrity. If Somaliland political elites and public opinion leaders are
truly sincere in their
aspirations for Somaliland, then better one grow out of
this political immaturity sooner than later.
Khaalid H. Hassan Mohamoud (Gadhweyne)
AFEEF:
Hadhwanaagnews marnaba masuul kama aha Aragtida dadka kale. Qoraaga ayaa xumaanteeda, xushmadeeda iyo xilkeeda sida. waxa kaliya oo Hadhwanaagmedia dhiirigalinaysaa, isdhaafsiga aragtida, canaanta gacaliyo talo wadaagga!